Main Club Sponsor - Bell Integrationshirt sponsor - R.R.SSponsor - Wrecking Coast Gin Distillery Mariners Sponsor - Turvey Construction
Back

Login

Powered By
Pitchero
1st XV Men
Matches
Sat 12 Sep 2026  ·  National League 2 East
Esher
48
12
Havant Rugby Football Club
1st XV Men
Tries: S Shepherd, W PerryConversions: J KnightSent Off: Unknown
Defeat at Esher

Defeat at Esher

Pete Mayhead

#UPTHEHILL

In a poor performance, Havant were beaten by an Esher side that dominated all facets of play and made good use of the windy conditions when they had them, in the first half. For Havant, a solid display in the tight for the first 20 minutes gradually fell apart, with almost no lineout ball won in the second half when they got field position. Poor defence at times let Esher find space through the middle, and two tries came from Havant ‘falling asleep’ when Esher scored unopposed close to the try line. Havant found the Esher new signing Charlie Cadogan hard to handle, which made it a bit baffling that the ball was kicked in his direction in the second half on a few occasions.

Things look challenging at scrum-half in the immediate future. Ben Holt went off in the first half with an injury that looks like it will keep him out for a while. His replacement, Colin Sisk, will receive a ban for his red card for what the referee adjudged to be a boot to the head of an opposing player. The players are adamant that he was trying to kick away the hand of a player holding him. He certainly isn’t a dirty player in any way. If Ben Holt’s injury does mean a break for him, Sam Trodd will likely move in from the wing, and Havant followers will remember how well he played against Oundle last season. Take two positives from any game they say, even when well-beaten. Here are three. Havant, although hugely vulnerable defensively in the midfield to players running on at pace, are a fortress at protecting the line when their opponents are trying to use their forwards to punch holes. This match was no exception. Will Perry scored a good try from a move in the backs in the second half, although he was well-marshalled for the most part. Ben Raivalitia, on for his first Havant appearance, made two good half-breaks late in the match that could have led to more.

Havant kicked off, Esher returned the ball in the air and Havant immediately knocked on. Not a great start. Esher had all the ball for the first four minutes, slowly grinding their way to Havant’s ‘22’ until Havant eventually turned the ball over. Havant showed intent. An early lineout won gave Reuben Knight the chance to put a lovely, floated pass out wide to Dylan Evans who made 40 metres. He couldn’t quite get his pass away on the outside, but for the first time Havant were in the Esher half. Havant were penalised at the next ruck and Esher kicked to the Havant ‘22’ on 6’.

Esher soon scored their first try. A missed tackle in midfield gave the Esher centre, Miles Rawstron-Rudd, the space he needed to break through and score. The try was converted by Matt Dalrymple. 7-0 on 8’. Havant responded quickly. A penalty awarded at the scrum went to touch (7m out) where Alex Hayton took a clean ball, the forwards rumbled on and Sean Shepherd received a pass on the left to score. 7-5 after 10’ with the conversion missed.

Havant then played a bit between their own ‘22’ and 10m line searching for holes in the Esher defence. A long pass from (I think) Jacob Knight, found Will Perry and he had space to move in. The pass was adjudged forward (and it was). At this point Ben Holt went off with his injury, taking a poor pass going backwards and getting thumped (legally) by an Esher forward. It was now all Esher, certainly in terms of territory. A penalty awarded to Esher saw a Havant side fail to react, and Esher scrum-half Pierre Thompson went over unopposed. Dalrymple converted again to make it 14-5 on 15’.

The Havant scrum was strong at this stage and a scrum penalty gave cause for hope with Havant back in the Esher half for the first time for an age. The lineout, however, was lost, and Esher got the ball away from danger. Havant were getting some possession. After the Esher escape, Havant were back in the Esher half having earned another penalty on around 19’. The good work was undone from a dropped Havant ball which Esher recycled and, after a few forward salvoes, Pierre Thompson went over again with Dalrymple also converting to make it 21-5 on 23’. Both Thompson tries had come from basic Havant errors.

Esher were now dominating possession and when Matt Dalrymple went over for the try bonus on 27’ it was looking difficult for the visitors, although he did miss the conversion. Now 26-5. Havant did have attacking chances. Two good ‘snipes’ from Colin Sisk and one from Angus Southon got Havant to the Esher ‘22’ but the ball was again knocked on and then a lineout offence for holding was penalised and gave Esher possession in the Havant half. Steve Jenkinson came on for Tam Lindsay (who would return later) on 35’.

Havant lacked continuity and this amateur observer felt we were failing to protect the ball at the ruck with too few player resources being used to speed up recycling. As a result, players were taking the ball standing still or with two defenders already on them. Into the last five minutes of the half, Havant were actually defending their line well from Esher forward thrusts. They turned over the ball and found touch. Havant won the lineout and kicked upfield but straight to wing Charlie Cadogan, who made a scything break into the heart of Havant’s now splintering defence. Havant were penalised at the ensuing ruck, Esher kicked for the corner and from the lineout a hooker, Lewis Pickford, touched down. Dalrymple converted to make it 33-5 at half-time.

The first twenty minutes of the second half were competitive with Havant scoring the only try.

Freddie Ferson was replaced by Will Butterwick at half-time, Jack Wright came on for Sean Shepherd, and Ben Raivalitia made his first Havant appearance, replacing Dylan Evans. The Esher wing, Charlie Cadogan, continued to make a nuisance of himself. Havant were largely containing Esher, with the wind helping to an extent. A Havant penalty was missed to touch but the forwards did manage to retrieve the ball. A half-break by Ben Raivalitia gave the ‘go-forward’ ball the team were looking for and Tom Gwyther was able to send Will Perry over out wide. A good conversion from Jacob Knight made it 33-12 on 48’ with Havant looking for the two more scores that would bring the try bonus at the very least. With the wind in their favour and Esher not quite showing their first-half bite, it was possible.

Esher, however, picked up their performance level once more, and should have scored when their second-row forward, Dan Cooke, dropped the ball (the pass was poor) close to the try line. Havant hoofed the ball all the way to inches from the Esher line, with the help of the wind. Havant were slow to chase, giving defender Cadogan the chance to kick all the way to the 10m line and touch.

A curio … last week Angus Southon showed his running skills, this week his footballing skills as he side-footed the ball 5m to the right of several advancing defenders and picked up the ball himself with defenders flummoxed. It’s the first time I have ever seen that on a rugby pitch.

Esher were giving away penalties themselves and it did start to look like the side could take something back to Hooks Lane. A penalty kicked to 5m on 55’ gave Havant a great opportunity to score their third but the ball got stuck in the maul. Although it was a bitty second half, Havant were mostly in the Esher half. However, poor passing and slow recycling in particular were making it hard for the side to get some rhythm in their play.

Then came the defining moment. Esher got to Havant’s ‘22’ for the first time for ages, and the red card came out for Colin Sisk’s perceived offence, with the Esher second-row forward, Dan Cooke, yellow-carded (presumably the player holding Colin Sisk back). Havant still weren’t playing well, even with good field position, but from here the life was sucked out of their performance.

Esher scored right away, with Esher’s full-back, Harry Faulkner, touching down in the right-hand corner on 60’. The conversion was missed, making it 38-12 on 62’. Two minutes later a lineout on the Havant ‘22’ saw replacement Josh Thorn catch the ball and run all the way to Havant’s line without hindrance. 43-12 on 64’ with the conversion missed again. Havant’s lineout had ceased to function as a defensive and attacking weapon, with quality possession also becoming almost non-existent.

The final score came from a lineout on the Havant ‘22’ and replacement hooker Sam Westmacott went over after a series of mauls. The conversion was again missed, making it 48-12 on 70’. Havant did spend an extended period of time attacking, including a four-minute period when Esher didn’t seem to get the ball. But really the side didn’t look like scoring, although a Ben Raivalitia break did look promising until the ball was lost at the ruck.

Match details

Match date

Sat 12 Sep 2026

Kickoff

15:00

Meet time

13:15

Location

Competition

National League 2 East

League position

8
Esher
11
Havant
Further reading

Team Sponsors

Main Club Sponsor - Bell Integration
shirt sponsor - R.R.S
Sponsor - Sarto &Thomas